From Diet Coke to Ovulation Timing: The Wildest Gender Prediction Theories Reddit Parents Swear By

Intro

Pregnancy comes with two guarantees: everyone will ask how you’re feeling, and everyone has opinions about whether you’re having a boy or girl. From the stranger in the grocery store to your grandma’s neighbor’s cousin, people love to share their “tried-and-true” tricks.

Sure, science tells us that a baby’s sex is determined by chromosomes. But in practice? Parents love swapping theories — some passed down for generations, some borrowed from pop culture, and some that are just plain hilarious.

We found a Reddit thread in r/BabyBumps that proves just how creative (and funny) people can get. Over 20,000 readers chimed in to share the wildest gender prediction hacks they’ve ever heard — from Diet Coke to shower temperature. Here are the best ones, grouped by theme.

Bedroom “Logic”

💬 “If a man pumps at the end it’ll be a boy. If he just holds it there it’ll be a girl.” — u/Difficult_Two_2201
💬 “If the woman orgasms first, it’s going to be a girl.” — u/ifbrainswerenoodles
💬 “Sex before ovulation for a girl, right after for a boy.” — u/sabdariffa

The Shettles Method (The “Scientific” One)

💬 “Look up the Shettles Method. Girls = a few days before ovulation, Boys = right at ovulation.” — u/primateperson
💬 “My MIL swears by this one. She apparently chose all 5 of her kids’ genders this way.” — u/West-Climate4879
💬 “We conceived five days before and are having a boy. So… maybe it works?” — u/tinyalley

‍

{{trendingoffer}}

‍

‍

Food Rules & Cravings

💬 “Follow the Sims 4 tricks! Girl = watermelon & strawberries. Boy = apples & carrots.” — u/Uncoordinated_Bee
💬 “Lots of potatoes, bananas, and potassium for boys. Diet Coke for girls.” — u/HannahJulie
💬 “Warm showers = boys. Warm balls = girls.” — u/newmanbeing & u/ullatron

Old Wives’ Tales Reimagined

💬 “A stranger told my partner to keep his shoes on if we wanted a girl.” — u/Sea_Juice_285
💬 “Tudor-era theory: virile thoughts + clenched fists = boy.” — u/Jumpy-Cranberry-1633
💬 “Eating red meat before conception increases chances of a boy.” — u/Mokelachild

Stress Theories

💬 “High-stress environments produce girls. I had 15 new clients the week I conceived, so definitely a girl.” — u/wocsdrawkcab
💬 “Male fetuses are more fragile, so stress tips toward girls.” — u/Onetwodash

Myth vs. Fact: What Science Actually Says

• Myth: Orgasm timing determines the baby’s sex.
  Fact: The sex of a baby is determined solely by whether an X or Y chromosome sperm fertilizes the egg. Timing doesn’t change that.
• Myth: Eating Diet Coke, bananas, or strawberries can sway gender.
  Fact: Diet plays no role in choosing a baby’s sex. Though cravings are very real, they’re a result of pregnancy, not a predictor.
• Myth: Stress guarantees you’ll have a girl.
  Fact: Stress can affect fertility overall, but there’s no consistent evidence that it influences sex determination.
• Myth: The Shettles Method works.
  Fact: Some parents swear by it, but scientific reviews say the odds don’t improve beyond the natural 50/50 chance.

In short? No food, no sex position, and no old wives’ tale can guarantee the outcome. But that doesn’t stop these myths from living on — and making pregnancy a little more entertaining.

Why We Love This Thread

It’s easy to laugh at these theories (and you should), but they also reveal something beautiful: the way parents find community by sharing stories, even the weird ones. Whether you’re sipping Diet Coke, timing ovulation, or just leaving it all to chance, talking about it makes the waiting game a little lighter.

Because in the end, no matter how creative the “science” sounds, baby gender still comes down to a 50/50 chance. But sharing myths, tips, and laughs? That’s what makes the pregnancy journey feel less lonely.

🎉 Try Villie’s Gender Predictor (for Fun!)

If you loved reading these wild Reddit takes, you’ll love putting your own guesses to the test. On Villie, you can play our Gender Predictor Game with your family and friends.

• Invite your whole village to vote whether they think you’re having a boy or girl
• Add prizes or surprises for the people who get it right
• Build hype for your big reveal (and keep everyone engaged on your Baby Page)

Because whether the internet swears by Diet Coke, ovulation timing, or “warm balls = girl,” the best part is celebrating together.

👉 Try the Gender Predictor Game now on your Baby Page 💜

‍

{{subscribe}}